Halloween Candy Pairings
Who says trick-or-treating is just for kids? 🍬 At The Good Pour, we’re keeping things spirited this Halloween with a lineup of wine and whiskey pairings that make the candy bowl twice as fun. Whether you’re sneaking a few Reese’s after the trick-or-treaters head home or hosting a costume party with friends, these pairings are guaranteed to hit that sweet spot.
Here’s your ultimate guide to pairing your favorite Halloween candy with some equally delightful pours.
🥜 Maker’s Mark & Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups
Soft and sweet with notes of caramel and vanilla, Maker’s Mark meets its match in the chocolatey, peanut-butter richness of Reese’s. Together, they’re a perfect blend of creamy, nutty and nostalgic.
Maker's Mark Kentucky Straight Bourbon
Made with soft red winter wheat instead of rye for a smoother, full-flavored pour. Every barrel is rotated by hand, aged to taste — not time — and finished with that iconic red wax dip. 45% ABV.
🍯 Basil Hayden Bourbon & Milk Duds
Light, approachable, and a little spicy, Basil Hayden highlights the chewy caramel and chocolate of Milk Duds — an elegant twist on a movie-theater classic.
Basil Hayden Bourbon
A high-rye Small Batch bourbon inspired by an 1800s Kentucky distilling pioneer. Refined and approachable with gentle spice, light caramel, and a smooth, easy finish. A gateway bourbon done right. 40% ABV.
🇯🇵 Toki Whisky & Kit Kat
Delicate and floral with hints of citrus, Toki Whisky is pure fun when paired with a Kit Kat bar (bonus points if it’s the green tea version). The balanced sweetness mirrors Toki’s soft, gentle style — a playful nod to Japanese harmony.
Suntory Toki Blended Japanese Whisky
A blend of Hakushu, Yamazaki, and Chita whiskies from the House of Suntory. Light and smooth with honey, green apple, and a hint of basil — exceptionally versatile neat or in a highball. 43% ABV.
🍋 El Tesoro Tequila & Lemonheads
Earthy, herbal and bright, El Tesoro’s 100% agave character pairs perfectly with the tart kick of Lemonheads. The citrusy punch and peppery zest make this an unexpectedly delicious match.
El Tesoro Blanco Tequila
Unaged and bottled immediately after distillation to capture the pure essence of highland Blue Weber agave. The minerality of the soil and water shines through in this traditional, agave-forward tequila. 40% ABV.
🌿 Roku Gin & 3 Musketeers
The subtle botanicals of Roku Gin meet the airy, chocolatey sweetness of a 3 Musketeers bar. Light, smooth, and unexpectedly harmonious—this pairing is like a refined twist on your favorite childhood treat.
Suntory Roku Japanese Gin
Six Japanese botanicals — sakura flower, sakura leaf, yuzu peel, sencha, gyokuro tea, and sanshō pepper — each harvested at peak season and blended with eight traditional botanicals. Perfectly balanced. 43% ABV.
🧸 -196 Vodka Seltzers & Gummy Bears
Effervescent and crisp, -196 Vodka Seltzers balance the chewy, fruity sweetness of gummy bears perfectly. Each sip pops with refreshing bubbles, making it a playful, adult-approved candy combo.
Suntory −196 Vodka Seltzer Variety Pack
Four bold whole-fruit flavor pairings — Lemon & Lime, Lemon & Raspberry, Strawberry & Watermelon, Strawberry & Pineapple. Eight cans of crisp, refreshing taste. 5.5% ABV.
🍫 Sequoia Grove Cabernet Sauvignon & Snickers
This Napa Cab brings structure and depth, ideal for standing up to Snickers’ caramel, nougat, and chocolate layers. It’s the ultimate grown-up take on a Halloween favorite.
Sequoia Grove Napa Cabernet Sauvignon
Blackberry cobbler, plum, and black currant on the nose with hints of tobacco and vanilla. Silky and lively on the palate — black cherry, raspberry, and a mouthwatering finish of cocoa. Classic Rutherford. 14.9% ABV.
🥜 Bezel Chardonnay & Butterfinger
Nutty, toasty and a little creamy, this Chardonnay echoes the peanut-butter crispiness of a Butterfinger. A pairing that’s both playful and perfectly balanced.
Bezel SLO Central Coast Chardonnay
From Edna Valley’s cool coastal climate, this Chardonnay delivers bright citrus and floral notes in a light, refreshing style. Barrel-aged with a light touch to let the fresh fruit shine. 13.5% ABV.
🍾 Poema Brut Cava & Sour Patch Kids
First they’re sour, then they’re sweet — and so is this pairing. The Cava’s crisp bubbles and citrus notes make a refreshing match for the tangy sugar rush of Sour Patch Kids.
Poema Cava Brut
Small-production Spanish Cava made by the traditional Champagne method from 20-year-old Barcelona vines. Fresh citrus, Granny Smith apple, mineral notes, and a hint of toasted bread. Excellent value in bubbles. 11.5% ABV.
