Halloween Candy Pairings

Who says trick-or-treating is just for kids? 🍬 At The Good Pour, we’re keeping things spirited this Halloween with a lineup of wine and whiskey pairings that make the candy bowl twice as fun. Whether you’re sneaking a few Reese’s after the trick-or-treaters head home or hosting a costume party with friends, these pairings are guaranteed to hit that sweet spot.

Here’s your ultimate guide to pairing your favorite Halloween candy with some equally delightful pours.

🥜 Maker’s Mark & Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups

Soft and sweet with notes of caramel and vanilla, Maker’s Mark meets its match in the chocolatey, peanut-butter richness of Reese’s. Together, they’re a perfect blend of creamy, nutty and nostalgic.

🪵 Knob Creek & Heath Bar

Bold and full-bodied, Knob Creek’s oak and spice flavors stand tall beside a crunchy Heath Bar. The toffee and chocolate bring out the bourbon’s smoky sweetness in every bite.

🍯 Basil Hayden Bourbon & Milk Duds

Light, approachable, and a little spicy, Basil Hayden highlights the chewy caramel and chocolate of Milk Duds — an elegant twist on a movie-theater classic.

🇯🇵 Toki Whisky & Kit Kat

Delicate and floral with hints of citrus, Toki Whisky is pure fun when paired with a Kit Kat bar (bonus points if it’s the green tea version). The balanced sweetness mirrors Toki’s soft, gentle style — a playful nod to Japanese harmony.

🍋 El Tesoro Tequila & Lemonheads

Earthy, herbal and bright, El Tesoro’s 100% agave character pairs perfectly with the tart kick of Lemonheads. The citrusy punch and peppery zest make this an unexpectedly delicious match.

🌿 Roku Gin & 3 Musketeers

The subtle botanicals of Roku Gin meet the airy, chocolatey sweetness of a 3 Musketeers bar. Light, smooth, and unexpectedly harmonious—this pairing is like a refined twist on your favorite childhood treat.

🧸 -196 Vodka Seltzers & Gummy Bears

Effervescent and crisp, -196 Vodka Seltzers balance the chewy, fruity sweetness of gummy bears perfectly. Each sip pops with refreshing bubbles, making it a playful, adult-approved candy combo.

🍫 Sequoia Grove Cabernet Sauvignon & Snickers

This Napa Cab brings structure and depth, ideal for standing up to Snickers’ caramel, nougat, and chocolate layers. It’s the ultimate grown-up take on a Halloween favorite.

🍷 Bezel Cabernet Sauvignon & Milk Duds

From Paso Robles, Bezel Cab’s ripe, round fruit complements the chewy caramel of Milk Duds — smooth, satisfying and just indulgent enough.

🥜 Bezel Chardonnay & Butterfinger

Nutty, toasty and a little creamy, this Chardonnay echoes the peanut-butter crispiness of a Butterfinger. A pairing that’s both playful and perfectly balanced.

🍒 Bezel Pinot Noir & Twizzlers

Light and fruit-forward, Bezel Pinot Noir is made for fun-sized red candies. Twizzlers’ cherry sweetness pairs beautifully with the wine’s bright berry notes.

🍾 Poema Brut Cava & Sour Patch Kids

First they’re sour, then they’re sweet — and so is this pairing. The Cava’s crisp bubbles and citrus notes make a refreshing match for the tangy sugar rush of Sour Patch Kids.

🥂 Taittinger Brut Champagne & Kit Kat

Elegant yet fun, Taittinger’s light and crisp bubbles play beautifully with a Kit Kat’s crunch. A little sparkle, a little snap — what’s not to love?